Please help with Traditional vs. Roth vs. Backdoor

[DMFA]

Doc_science wrote:

#1) Yes, we contributed before April 2017 for 2016. So wondering what the optimum timing for the contribution for 2017 would be. And what the optimum timing for the conversion also. Should we do the conversion twice? As in, do it now for the 2016 funds, contribute for 2017 and do another conversion? Or just contribute to 2017 and do one conversion for all?

#2) Makes sense, that is why I will open a Roth IRA at fidelity in my account today. When we do the conversion for my wife, we would just transfer the funds to the pre-existing Roth IRA right?

#3) ASAP? Just for clarification, my $5500 in my traditional IRA account grew ~ 22% via the Contrafund. I know if I do the backdoor Roth, I will be taxed on the gains, but I still feel as though the Roth conversion will be beneficial in retirement for me.

Am I making this harder than it should be?

Thanks for your help!

Click to expand...

I am making the assumption that you can't deduct your Traditional IRA contributions since you should have an employer account.

1. Contribute whenever you have $5,500 to do so.  Convert right after contributing.  It doesn't matter if you convert them sequentially or together.  Why wait, other than market timing (which is generally ill-advised)?  You should convert right after you contribute: that way, there are zero gains to be taxed.  Leave it in the sweep account (SPAXX or whatever cash/money market fund) until it's in the Roth, then buy holdings with it after it's converted.

2. Yes, you'd transfer from the Traditional to the pre-existing Roth.  You don't need to create a new Roth for this, and shouldn't need to create a new Traditional for your next conversion.  One Roth, one Traditional (which will have $0 in it for like 51 weeks out of the year) per person.

3. So you want to wait until it grows more so that more of it is taxable?  If you're in the top bracket now, you'd owe about $480 in taxes.  If you'd converted the next day after your contribution, you'd probably owe zero.  If you convert in 20 years after 5% growth in the 25% bracket, you'd owe about $3,648 in taxes.  If you can't deduct your contributions, there's no point in doing tax-deferred instead of tax-free growth.  Maybe you could wait until there's a bear market to do your conversion so that you have less gains to be taxed, which is not unreasonable...you've got to wonder how long the market could be at these all-time highs.  Anyway, a $480 tax bill on a Roth conversion is peanuts.

[Doc_science]

#1) Yes, we contributed before April 2017 for 2016. So wondering what the optimum timing for the contribution for 2017 would be. And what the optimum timing for the conversion also. Should we do the conversion twice? As in, do it now for the 2016 funds, contribute for 2017 and do another conversion? Or just contribute to 2017 and do one conversion for all?

#2) Makes sense, that is why I will open a Roth IRA at fidelity in my account today. When we do the conversion for my wife, we would just transfer the funds to the pre-existing Roth IRA right?

#3) ASAP? Just for clarification, my $5500 in my traditional IRA account grew ~ 22% via the Contrafund. I know if I do the backdoor Roth, I will be taxed on the gains, but I still feel as though the Roth conversion will be beneficial in retirement for me.

Am I making this harder than it should be?

Thanks for your help!

[DMFA]

Doc_science wrote:

Another amateur dummy physician investor with lots of questions! Ha!

Starting to manage both, my wife and I’s (grammar?) IRA accounts through Fidelity. Just got married about 8 months ago.

I am a new attending and as such, didn’t open a Roth in the past and secondary to our combined salary > $196K, can only contribute to a traditional IRA.

#1) Did we do that right? We contributed $5500 and $5500 to our traditional accounts before April 2017 and plan to do so again before April 2018.

Wife had a Roth IRA that she was contributing to before we got married that has ~ $11K in it.

#2) Should I open a Roth IRA account in my Fidelity account also?

#3) When should we convert our traditional IRA money into a Roth IRA account? As soon as possible? After we contribute another $5500 in each before April 2018?

Thanks for all the help!

Click to expand...

1. Do you mean you contributed those amounts prior to April 2017 *for* 2016?  Did you file those contributions on your 2016 taxes?  You can contribute *for* 2017 anytime from 1/1/2017 to 4/17/2018.  Any conversions done *in* 2017 will be shown on your taxes this coming year.

2. Yes, since it's very unlikely you can deduct your contributions, and non-deductible traditional IRAs are suboptimal.

3. ASAP, generally before it grows so there's no tax due on it, assuming you have no money in pretax IRAs (traditional, SEP, SIMPLE) at the end of the year.  If you have a lot of money in pretax IRAs [note this does NOT include 401(k), 403(b), 457, HSA], then it may not be worth it for you since the conversions are taxed pro rata, but one spouse's pretax accounts do NOT affect the other's.

[Doc_science]

Another amateur dummy physician investor with lots of questions! Ha!

Starting to manage both, my wife and I's (grammar?) IRA accounts through Fidelity. Just got married about 8 months ago.

I am a new attending and as such, didn't open a Roth in the past and secondary to our combined salary > $196K, can only contribute to a traditional IRA.

#1) Did we do that right? We contributed $5500 and $5500 to our traditional accounts before April 2017 and plan to do so again before April 2018.

Wife had a Roth IRA that she was contributing to before we got married that has ~ $11K in it.

#2) Should I open a Roth IRA account in my Fidelity account also?

#3) When should we convert our traditional IRA money into a Roth IRA account? As soon as possible? After we contribute another $5500 in each before April 2018?

Thanks for all the help!